Re: CMS Advice

From: Jason Dwyer (Jason.Dwye..edata.com.au)
Date: Fri Oct 28 2005 - 19:31:45 EDT

  • Next message: Andrus Adamchik: "Re: CMS Advice"

    Andrus,

    php works fine with postgres and a number of other db's besides mysql:
    redhat linuxes will ship with a number of php packages, including
    php-pgsql, php-mysql and php-odbc.

    not that i'm a huge fan of php, but on this point alone you shouldnt
    discount it.

    more to the point, the cms system will be the limiting factor in db
    choice. i also prefer postgres to mysql, but for ready made systems, i
    dont think it matters too much, and of the open source cms's the vast
    majority will be on mysql.

    have you considered a home grown system?

    j

    On Fri, 2005-10-28 at 17:41 -0400, Andrus Adamchik wrote:

    > This post is more related to Cayenne community rather than Cayenne
    > technology...
    >
    > I've been looking for an easy to use content management system for
    > ObjectStyle.org web site (and of course for its Cayenne part). Our
    > current system (aside from Confluence and Jira) consisting of XML
    > files that need to be checked out from CVS, edited by hand, and then
    > rebuilt with Ant/Velocity, clearly outlived itself. There is lots of
    > other choices out there, though none seem to be good enough to
    > warrant the switch. Features I am looking for are the following:
    >
    > 1. Content posting by authenticated users. This includes online
    > editing of any part of the static site.
    > 2. Support for 100% custom templates to ensure the site is structured
    > and looks the way *we* want it.
    > 3. An ability to grab external RSS feeds and post them under news
    > section (right now we can't even scrape our own blog).
    > 4. We need to be able to maintain User and Modeler Guides in one
    > place and then publish them in two places - on the web site and as
    > part of release documentation.
    >
    > Confluence (not sure about the new versions) won't work - it doesn't
    > address (2) and (3). Most open source CMS's are written in PHP
    > (surprise!). I have no prejudice against PHP, aside from the fact
    > that it only works with MySQL, so I evaluated a few packages. The
    > winners were Drupal and WordPress. On the surface Drupal addresses
    > all the requirements except for (4), but I quickly got lost in its
    > configuration menus. I didn't feel like I gained any productivity
    > compared to our current checkout/edit-by-hand/deploy approach.
    > WordPress had nice UI for publishing (and a lot of nonsense
    > surrounding it), but didn't allow to embed RSS. I even invested some
    > money to do a pilot project integrating Drupal, WordPress and our
    > current Velocity templates, but the result was simply too complex to
    > maintain.
    >
    > So now I am doing what I should've done long time ago - asking for
    > community advice. Anyone knows of a simple CMS that satisfies all the
    > requirements above and is still simple to use and maintain? Open
    > source systems that work with PostgreSQL are preferred. Of course
    > commercial programs that would donate a license to an open source
    > project would work too.
    >
    > Alternatively if you have experience configuring systems like Drupal
    > (if I am not mistaken, Spring uses Drupal, and their site is not that
    > bad), and can volunteer to do a prototype of a Drupal site (and help
    > me with a "mentality switch" part), please let me know.
    >
    > Thanks
    > Andrus



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2.0.0 : Fri Oct 28 2005 - 19:32:26 EDT